Among the Mennonites

Tonight we held our fourth community Lenten service, this one at the Mennonite church. I had never before really noticed the Church of Christ, the Presbyterian church, or this Mennonite church. Nor have I noticed the Methodist church where we'll be next week. That's pretty sad. These are fellow churches trying to reach our community, and I've been insulated from them. Sad.

But we're getting past that. We're learning a lot about each other, and that we have much in common.

I appreciated the Mennonite pastor and what he told us about Mennonite history and beliefs. Their pacifist stand is, obviously, a central piece of their puzzle. I do appreciate how the Mennonites are consistent in their pro-life ethic, as opposed to us "Republican evangelicals" who mix-and-match, depending on what our religious leaders tell us to believe--be anti-abortion but pro-death penalty, for instance. The Mennonites are consistent.

We United Brethren, with half of our roots being in the Mennonite tradition and half in the German Reformed, like it both ways when it comes to military service: it's okay to fight, and it's okay to be a conscientious objector. Me? There are aspects of pacifism that I just can't reconcile (like: "How should we have responded to Pearl Harbor?" and other questions that Mennonites probably get tired of hearing). I'm fine with "just war" scenarios (yes to Afghanistan, no to Iraq, though I favored going there initially). I guess if I spent more time with Mennonites and heard their responses to my objections, understanding might occur. Heaven forbid.

I didn't realize the "diaspora" element of being a Mennonite. To avoid compulsory military service, their people have moved from country to country. One nation might exempt them from military service, but a century later, some new regime takes over that "knows not Joseph." And so, they have to either find a new country, or accept military service. That was very interesting to me.

These five churches are holding a joint Vacation Bible School for the second year. Last year it was at the Presbyterian church. This year the Mennonites will host it.

As we all ate together in their downstairs fellowship hall, it struck me that many people, particularly fundamentalists, would be highly suspect of what we're doing. That amidst ecumenicalism, compromise and watering-down inevitably happens. Even some of you readers are looking at this warily. Aren't you?

Posted on March 18, 2007 11:08 PM|

Comments

The fact that your words would not be widely embraced by fellow UB-ers speaks volumes about demise of our forlorn fellowship. The simple truth is, our UB heritage shares more in common with Bishop Wright than it does with Otterbein and Boehm.

Posted by: Steve Gilbertson | March 21, 2007 02:18 PM

Post a comment

All comments are moderated, which means your comment won't appear until it's been approved. Thanks for your patience.

Name:
Email:
URL:
Comments:
(you may use HTML tags for style)